What is at stake
Hampden County's Trial Court employees, litigants, and the public are currently served by an aging courthouse. The new Hampden County Courthouse at 125 Liberty Street is intended to replace it with a modern, safe, accessible facility. Every additional month of litigation is a month those needs go unmet.
Liberty Junction's proposal was selected through DCAMM's procurement process. The company includes CoJo Partners and other development partners.
What the review found
Arguments presented in Hampden County Superior Court put the value of the selected proposal at $400 million or more in taxpayer savings compared with the losing bid. Justice Hodge's ruling separately found that Liberty Junction's total estimated cost of occupancy is $7.4 million lower than the next-closest finalist, and that the deal saves the Commonwealth roughly $600,000 per month compared with other proposals.
What the court decided
On August 24, 2026, Justice Hodge denied Balise and Patel's motions for a temporary restraining order and a preliminary injunction in a 29-page ruling. He found the plaintiffs had not shown a likelihood of success on the merits of their conflict-of-interest claim, and that DCAMM, not being a state employee, is not subject to the conflict-of-interest law the plaintiffs cited. The ruling did not dismiss the underlying case, and Balise and Patel have since filed a notice of appeal. The Massachusetts Attorney General has moved to dismiss the case entirely, calling the plaintiffs' legal theories "incorrect and inapplicable."
Who is challenging the deal, and why
The lawsuit was filed on July 9, 2026 by USPB JV, LLC, owned by New England used-car dealer Jeb Balise, and Springfield Tower Square LLC, owned by real-estate investor Dinesh Patel. Both entities submitted losing bids for the same courthouse contract that Liberty Junction won. Liberty Junction has described their suit as an attempt "to delay the project and recoup a lost bid." Co-founder Richard Mann said at the August 11 hearing: "Jeb Balise intends to stall that process."
Every delay has a cost
Liberty Junction has urged "the competitors to think of Hampden County residents and courthouse workers" and stop what it called "baseless legal delay tactics." A pending appeal and the Attorney General's motion to dismiss mean the case is not yet fully resolved. But the trial court's initial review has already tested the plaintiffs' central claims and found them unsupported.